Tweet
Refusing to move a semi-truck can be a firing offense, but it depends on the reason for the refusal
. Federal law, particularly the Surface Transportation Assistance Act (STAA) and the anti-coercion rule, protects drivers who refuse to drive for valid safety reasons. However, a driver can be disciplined or fired for refusing a load without a legitimate justification.
Legally protected reasons to refuse a load
Federal law prohibits employers from firing, disciplining, or retaliating against a driver for refusing to operate a vehicle for these specific safety-related reasons.
- Hours of Service (HOS) violations: A driver cannot be forced to take a load that would require them to exceed their legally mandated driving hours.
- Unsafe equipment: You can refuse to operate a semi-truck that is not in safe operating condition. This includes issues like faulty brakes, bad tires, or malfunctioning lights. The driver must inform the company of the problem and request a repair.
- Overweight or unbalanced load: A driver can refuse a load that is overweight or improperly balanced, as this is a safety hazard and a legal violation.
- Dangerous weather or road conditions: You have the right to refuse to drive if you believe conditions are too hazardous.
- Driver fatigue or illness: Driving while tired or ill can impair judgment and is protected under the STAA.
- Unqualified to haul: You can refuse a load you are not legally qualified to transport, such as a hazardous materials shipment for which you lack the required endorsement.
If the refusal is not based on a legitimate safety concern, a company can terminate a driver for refusing a load.
- Insubordination: Refusing a legally sound dispatch order without a valid safety reason can be seen as insubordination. Many carriers operate under "forced dispatch" policies, and turning down loads unnecessarily can be a fireable offense, though not all companies enforce it strictly.
- Contractual obligations: While independent owner-operators have more freedom to refuse loads, company drivers are typically subject to stricter company policies. An unjustified refusal could violate your employment contract.
- Consistent pattern of refusal: Even in "no forced dispatch" environments, a driver who frequently refuses loads for poor or unsubstantiated reasons may be flagged as unreliable and could eventually be let go.
If you are fired for refusing an unsafe or illegal load, federal protections are in place.
- Document everything: Record the specific safety violation and your refusal to operate the vehicle. Keep copies of communications with your dispatcher.
- File a complaint with OSHA: The Surface Transportation Assistance Act (STAA) gives you 180 days to file a whistleblower retaliation complaint with the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA).
- Contact an attorney: An employment lawyer can help you understand your rights and build a case for wrongful termination. Successful claims can result in back pay, compensatory damages, and even reinstatement.